Lending Club Review – 2 Years, 6.23% Return, 5 Loans Charged Off

Be sure to check out my Lending Club review from 6 months ago and my analysis of charged off (defaulted) LC notes.

Lendingclub.com continues to deliver superior investment returns while minimizing risk. Since my review 6 months ago, my net annualized return has decreased by 2.12 percentage points (from 8.35% to 6.23%). While this isn’t the direction I’d like to be going, I expected this result based on having 4 loans 31-120 days late when I last wrote 6 months ago.

In fact, I’m pretty excited that, while I am seeing a lower net annualized return, I haven’t had any more defaults. I believe that this is mostly due to being more selective in the notes I invest in and not just choosing randomly or based on the grade or interest rate.

In the last 6 months I haven’t made any new deposits or withdrawals from my Lending Club account. I’ve seen 3 loans fully paid, 4 loans get charged off, and I’ve added 14 new loans to my portfolio.

In the past I’ve used a variety of criteria to select my loans. Obviously, with only a 6% return, when Lending Club advertises a 9.6% return, I need a new strategy.

My New 2013 Lending Club Investment Strategy

Smarter Investing with Lending ClubThis strategy is based primarily on the research I performed on avoiding charged off loans, as well as reading other Lending Club investment strategies. Many Lending Club users are seeing double digit returns, so it’s a bit embarrassing for me, after 24 months of investing, to still be posting 6-8% returns.

My new 2013 strategy for selecting Lending Club notes looks like this:

  • Loan Grade: C, D only
  • Deliquincies in the past 2 years: 1
  • Monthly Income: >=$7500
  • Loan purpose: all except Vacation, Small Business, and Other

That’s it. Very simple, but LendStats.com shows that if I had used this strategy since 2010, I could have expected a 10.43% return, only a 3.91% default rate, and still had over 6000 loans to select from. I’ll put any new loans purchased under this scheme into a specific portfolio and report back on my results.

My goal with Lending Club has always been to generate 10% returns while minimizing my charged off and defaulted loans. I hope to make that goal a reality with this new strategy.

My Exact Lending Club Results After 2 Years

lending-club-returns-review-scam-resultsSo after two years of investing in Lending Club, here are my results. Remember, this was with almost no research and a very relaxed approach to selecting which loans were invested in. Had I taken more time to research, I’m sure my return could have been much greater.

A 5% return is not negligible, especially when there was no work done on my part, CD and savings accounts interest rates are so low, and this is an investment very uncorrelated to stock market or property value performance. In an era of low FDIC insured interest rates and an extremely volatile and possibly overpriced stock market, Lending Club offers just one more way to diversify your income and investments.

Loan Performance Summary.

ROI:5.1% (+-0.43%)
Rate of Loss:5.36%
Total Lent:87 loans, $2,158
Remaining:$1,169
Net Gain:$112 (+-$10)
Markups Paid:$2
Average Credit Grade:C1
Average Interest Rate:12.23%
Average Loan Age:16.5 months

Lending Club is still mostly an experimental investment opportunity for me. My main focus right now is paying off my student loans, investing in the stock market through Roth TSP, and building my savings for eventual early retirement at age 40. As my student loans get paid off, I expect to begin routing more money every month into my Lending Club account.

For further reading, look at my Lending Club review from 6 months ago and my analysis of charged off (defaulted) LC notes.

Let me know if you have an excellent Lending Club investment strategy in the comments! Share the wealth!

My Top Three Recommendations for Achieving Financial Independence While You Serve


1. Bank with a military friendly bank, like USAA. I've been a proud member of USAA for 6 years now and have never had a better customer experience with any other bank. They charge no BS fees, refund ATM fees, and have the best auto insurance prices for military servicemembers.

2. Use a cashback credit card, like the Barclaycard Arrival World Mastercard. How does a $440 sign up bonus, NO foreign transaction fees, and 2.2% cashback on every purchase sound? Read my review to see why I love this new card.

3. Track your growing investments using Personal Capital. In order to get where you want to go, you have to know where you are. Personal Capital is like Mint.com for investors. While Mint is good for tracking your expenses and getting out of debt, PC is good for seeing your wealth and investments accumulate and grow. Track your Roth TSP, Roth IRA, banking accounts, SDP, and the myriad of other accounts you have all in one place with Personal Capital. It's free and presents a beautiful graphical view of your financial situation. Join today to get the most complete picture of your finances. Read my full review here.

This entry was posted in Case Studies, Investing, Lending Club and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Lending Club Review – 2 Years, 6.23% Return, 5 Loans Charged Off

  1. Good luck MMM in changing your criteria and pulling your overall returns higher! I experienced something similar in my taxable LC account over the past four years and it has led me to climbing up to over a 10% rate of return!

  2. Pingback: Peer to Peer Lending News Roundup – March 9, 2013

  3. Will Fahmy says:

    You also have to remember that $1,000 will not allow you to diversify as much , so the 6% return might just be due to bad luck.

    • Very true, with a 10 or 20 thousand dollar portfolio the averages would definitely be more in my favor. A $1000 investment is just too few notes to spread the risk around.

  4. Mike says:

    I’m nearly up to my $10000 initial investment in LC before I put $10000 in Prosper so that I can do a proper comparison of the two.

    In addition to the filters I’ve talked about a few times over at my own site, I wonder if my thoughts on borrower psychology which has limited me to only taking on 3-year loans for debt consolidation purposes will ultimately return a higher than average rate. I guess only time will tell, but having a large number of notes should be a good test.

    As you point out, a 6 percent return is about 5 percent higher than CDs, savings accounts, etc., so I think this was still a good move on your part!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>