Why I’m Funding My Roth IRA and Not My Wife’s (For Now!)

Kate Horrell asked a great question on my 1 year financial plan post:

Spencer, I’d love to hear your logic about funding your IRA over your wife’s IRA. You have so many more earning and saving options, including TSP and possibly a military retirement check. Military spouses typically have lower lifetime earnings and find it very hard to maintain consistent employment, particularly in fields that offer 401k or 403b plans. They lose time from work with every PCS and if someone is going to stay home with the children, it is the spouse. A well-funded IRA is a much larger piece of a spousal retirement plan than it is for the active duty member. I always advise my clients that if they aren’t going to fund both, they should consider funding the spouse’s first.

Kate – thanks for the question, I’ll see if I can break this down, please let me know what you think:

Our Main Goal Right Now: Paying off Student Loans

Our goal right now is paying off my student loan debt. That is our highest priority. Mathematically, it’s only a few hundred dollars in interest saved versus potentially thousands of dollars if we invested the extra loan payments in another (not FDIC insured) investment. But the freedom from paying our creditors once we’re debt free is a powerful motivation, as well as the cash flow we’ll be freeing up. We’ve made the choice that we’d rather be debt free in a few years than have a few thousand dollars in our retirement/savings accounts. My wife’s already reached that goal, paying off $45,000 in student loans in under a year.

Now, if there were FDIC insured CDs or savings accounts offering 4-5% returns like there were in 2005-2008, you can bet that we would be crunching the numbers and probably making a different decision. But with interest rates so low, there’s no incentive to invest in the short term investments. Also, two of my loans are variable rate loans, and right now they’re under 3%, so it’d be great to knock them out while they’re still low.

So because our priority is student loan repayment, we’re not as focused on retirement funding.

…But We’re Still Investing for the Future

HOWEVER, I believe that not investing now would be a huge mistake. I won’t explain right now about the “if you start investing at 20 vs if you start investing at 30” charts, but essentially the earlier you start saving, the more time compounding interest has to go to work.

We decided that we would max out one of our retirement accounts while we paid back our student loans. We picked mine simply because my wife doesn’t have one open yet.

I looked into doing the TSP route when I came on active duty in 2010. Because at the time they weren’t offering a Roth option, I decided to just focus on my civilian Roth IRA.

Now that they offer a Roth option, I will probably start using that, after my student loans are paid off. We will also re-examine our retirement savings plan when the student loans are paid off, our income goes up, or something else big changes in our financial situation.

Early Retirement Funds

Another important factor for us is having access to cash and other assets before we reach “retirement age.” If we stick to our plan of having enough assets by age 40 to cover the 4% safe withdrawal rate, then we’re going to need 20 years of funds (from age 40-60) before we can access our normal retirement accounts (Roth IRA, IRA, TSP, etc).

This is going to require some investment vehicles outside of the normal retirement accounts, such as taxable brokerage accounts, Lending Club, CDs, maybe a military retirement package (although the earliest I would be eligible for this under current rules is 44).

And that, Kate, is my 657 word answer to your comment! Please let me know if you think I’m missing something here. I love getting feedback on my plans.

My Recommendations for Achieving Financial Independence


1. Bank with a military friendly bank, like USAA. I've been a proud member of USAA for 6 years now and have never had a better customer experience with any other bank. They charge no BS fees, refund ATM fees, and have the best auto insurance prices for military servicemembers.

2. Use a cashback credit card, like the Barclaycard Arrival World Mastercard. How does a $440 sign up bonus, NO foreign transaction fees, and 2.2% cashback on every purchase sound? Read my review to see why I love this new card.

3. Track your growing investments using Personal Capital. In order to get where you want to go, you have to know where you are. Personal Capital is like Mint.com for investors. While Mint is good for tracking your expenses and getting out of debt, PC is good for seeing your wealth and investments accumulate and grow. Track your Roth TSP, Roth IRA, banking accounts, SDP, and the myriad of other accounts you have all in one place with Personal Capital. It's free and presents a beautiful graphical view of your financial situation. Join today to get the most complete picture of your finances. Read my full review here.

This entry was posted in Budgeting, Case Studies, Student Loans. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Why I’m Funding My Roth IRA and Not My Wife’s (For Now!)

  1. Healthcare Army LT says:

    Remember, you can withdraw contributions from a Roth with no penalty and tax free at any time. This might help you plan better from age 40-60.

    Good hunting!

  2. Jan says:

    Hummmm-I agree with paying off loans BUT, I respectfully disagree with your decision about the IRA.
    She is moving every few years for your career- not building a pension.
    You should reciprocate and build Her IRA. It takes about five minutes to open one ( “mine is open” did you really use that as an excuse????).
    As a “retiree wife” it was essential that my IRA was always funded. To me it was a small way for “us” to show that my contribution was just as important to the family. We are both FI- together and independently. It is an under pinning to our 31 year marriage. No resentments.
    Something for you to seriously reconsider.
    BTW- An officer’s on call/retirement pay (you can be called back at any time until 60) is worth- easily- 1 million in the bank. “We” have been retired for 17 years and at 25 years “we” will have received almost million dollars in pay+ medical. You would be silly to walk away at age 40, in my humble, mother- like, opinion.

    • Spencer says:

      Pensions really aren’t an option at most companies any more, so that doesn’t really fit into the equation. We actually did just open a pension for her this year, and yes, it took about 5 minutes (so that wasn’t a good excuse!).

      As to walking away at age 40…I would have 4 more years until I would be eligible for my 20 year retirement. At this stage, I have no desire to be a career officer. Would I trade 4 of the best years of my life for an extra $50,000 for the rest of my life? I don’t know yet. But I want to be in the position where I get to choose. With $1.2 million in the bank at age 40, I’ll be able to make the choice without having to worry about how I’ll feed the family for the next 60 years. It’s all about freedom and choice, something the military is not very good about giving you.

      Thanks for the advice though, I do appreciate everyone’s input!

  3. Pingback: Saving and Investing on Your Military Deployment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>