I Hate Budgeting: 2015-2016 Expenses and Investments

14,542 grads of the Ultimate Military Credit Cards Course already know why
The Platinum Card® from American Express is my #1 recommended card

Military Money Manual has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products and may receive a commission from card issuers. Some or all of the cards that appear on this site are from advertisers and may impact how and where card products appear on the site. This site does not include all card companies or all available card offers. Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

Budgeting: why bother? I find budgeting to be a chore and would much rather focus my limited time for my finances on increasing my income and investing. We only have 168 hours in a week, 112 of which are spent awake if you get 8 hours of sleep. I like to maximize those 112 useful hours.

In the broadest sense, a budget is just a plan for your money. If you are paid regularly like most military employees, you should have at least a basic plan for your dollars that arrive every 1st and 15th of the month.

I set up my finances to invest automatically first and then not worry too much about what’s left over. It is amazing how fast your net worth grows when you automate your investments into the TSP and your Vanguard IRAs.

Paula Pant describes a simple budget on her blog called the “Anti-Budget.” It’s similar to how I budget my own money. Here’s the gist of it: automatically pay down debt, save a bit, and invest some. Then spend the rest on whatever you want.

Saving vs. Investing

Savings rate vs. years to work until financial independence from GoCurryCracker!
Savings rate vs. years to work until financial independence from GoCurryCracker!

I like to differentiate between saving and investing. Saving to me is setting aside money to be spent later, within the next week, month, or year. You should save a bit of every paycheck for the large annual or monthly expenses you know are coming: car maintenance, rent, mortgage payment, auto and renter’s insurance, cell phone plans, utilities, and Christmas. If you want a nice vacation to Argentina or Austin, put aside some money each month to cover your airfare, hotel, and expenses. This is savings to be spent, not savings for financial independence.

Investing is savings set aside for retirement or financial independence. This is money I will not touch for decades, or possibly ever. This is my stash of cash that sits in my TSP, Vanguard IRAs, and Betterment taxable account. Invested automatically in accordance with my asset allocation plan in simple, low cost, and diversified passive index funds, I expect this money to double roughly every 10 years.

When personal finance people discuss “savings rate,” I believe they are usually referring to “investment rate,” or the percentage of my income that they allocate towards long term investments. Savings rate, therefore, is a bit of a misnomer. Who cares if you save 100% of your income in one month only to spend it all the next? It’s important to differentiate between saving to spend and saving for financial freedom.

My Anti-Budget: Invest 50%, Spend the Rest

I keep things simple: I invest 50% of my income and spend the rest on the things and activities that make me, my wife, my family, and my friends happy.

For myself, when I had student loan debt that meant 50% of my income went towards debt repayment and investment. This is my long term wealth creation money which I always prioritize above lifestyle expenses and saving to spend. Some people call this “paying yourself first.”

Now that we’re debt free, I invest 50% of my paycheck automatically in the TSP, my IRAs, and my regular taxable account. You cannot achieve financial independence without income generating assets, whether it’s real estate, stocks, or bonds. You must have long term investments and not just cash sitting in a 0.1% APY bank account. After my long term investments, then I set aside a piece of my paycheck for lifestyle expenses.

To figure out how much of each paycheck to set aside, I estimate how much I think my spending will be in a particular month based on my previous spending data. I usually spend $100/month on gas? Each paycheck I’ll set aside $50 in a separate “gas” savings account. Insurance and auto maintenance was $1200 last year? I’ll set aside $60 per paycheck ($1440/year) just in case it’s a bit higher this year.

At the end of the year, I roll over any extra savings, invest them, or treat me and the wife for a night out. If I am off on my estimation for a particular month, I’ll bump it up next month so I do not get any surprises.

I try to put as many expenses as possible on my Chase Freedom and Chase Sapphire Preferred credit cards for the points. I have flown multiple times for free by using the points through Chase’s Ultimate Rewards program.

Easy Ways to Estimate Your Expenses

Some people get real in depth into tracking their budget and keeping themselves on budget. If they can keep it that up, good for them. I find it to be boring and waste of time. There are much more productive things I can do with my life than figure out how I spent an extra $20 on gas last month.

I still check my statements for fraudulent or inaccurate charges, but I don't track my expenses down to the dollar anymore. If you want a budget or need help estimating your expenses, here is a list of good, free budgeting tools:

I stopped tracking our spending fastidiously around 2013. All of the automated tracking programs I tried required too much maintenance. I never keep receipts and don’t keep track of each individual transaction. Ain’t nobody got time for that!

Rather than focusing on the pennies saved by budgeting tightly, I apply the Pareto principle and focus on cutting my big three expenses: housing, transportation, and food. Of all of our expense, these three represent 80% of our cost of living. By minimizing these expenses and investing 50% of my income into income producing assets, I can enjoy life and spend my leftover money how I choose.

Expenses for 2015

2015 was an expensive year for us. We had a PCS from Washington state to the East coast and we sold our condo in Washington. We also finished paying off our remaining $37,000 in auto and student loans, using the profits from the sale of the condo. We maxed out all of our retirement accounts for the first year since graduating college plus put a little into our taxable brokerage account.

In total, our expenses were around $81,000. The biggest expenses of the year were:

  • student loan debt repayment ($23,000)
  • transportation (around $22,000 paying off the auto loan, insurance, routine maintenance, and gas)
  • housing (about $18,000 in rent, security deposit, and mortgage payments)

The rest of our big expenses were:

  • groceries (about $4800)
  • dining out and entertainment ($3600)
  • two T-Mobile cell phones with unlimited talk, text, data, and international roaming ($2000)
  • Christmas presents ($1000)

Monthly Investments for 2016

For 2016, our monthly expenses should be lower than our last assignment and 2015 because we’re finally debt free. We’re planning on investing 50% of my income and all of my wife’s income. When you’re investing 50% of your income, you’re no more than 17 years away from financial independence (see chart above). We plan to be there before I turn 40.

I never chase performance when I invest. I did this when I was in high school with predictable results: negative or negligible returns. Now I invest based on my investing principles: automatic, simple, diversified, and low cost investments are my preferred vehicles for growing my earnings into wealth.

I do this with the TSP, Vanguard IRAs, and a Betterment taxable investment account and following my asset allocation plan. When I deploy for long enough I also pick up an SDP and keep that going for as long as I can.

For investments, I have scheduled the following contributions:

Traditional TSP

50% of my base pay: $2,643/month, $18,000 per year. I should max out my Traditional TSP by August. If I’m lucky enough to deploy in the end of the year, I’ll make additional contributions towards the $53,000 combat zone cap.

Traditional IRAs

$11,000 per year, $1100/month. We reduced the size of our emergency fund this year and made the full contribution to my wife’s Traditional IRA in January. My Trad IRA should be maxed out by August. Read more on Traditional vs. Roth at the MadFientist. In my research, if you are paying any taxes in a year it makes sense to reduce your tax burden with a Traditional account. If you are an E-5 or below or O-1/O-2, then a Roth may make more sense depending on your spouse’s income.

Taxable Investment Accounts

Once our tax advantaged retirement accounts are maximized for the year, we will make additional investments in our taxable investment accounts at Betterment and Vanguard. This should be around $3600/month from August onward. My plan this year is to get my Betterment account over $10,000 so the expense ratio will drop to 0.25%. After that, additional investments will be made in our Vanguard taxable account. My Betterment account is set to 90% stocks, 10% bonds and the rest of my 2016 asset allocation is described here.

2016 Expenses

Our largest expense in 2016 will be the two bedroom house we’re renting at $1450/month ($17,400/year). Other than that, we expect to spend $400/month on groceries ($4800/year), and $300/month on going out, entertainment, drinks, dinner, etc. ($3600/year). Transportation thankfully drops to around $4800 for insurance, maintenance, and fuel. We really like our Mazda 3, but we are eyeing an upgrade to the Tesla 3 when it becomes widely available. Hopefully in 2020!

Financial Independence Update

Currently, our invested assets could replace about 10% of our monthly expenses using the 4% rule. However, I anticipate our monthly expenses to drop considerably when we become financially independent. For instance, our worldwide enabled T-Mobile cell phones, costing us $130/month, could easily be replaced by pay-as-you-go sim cards costing less than $50/month. Our housing costs should also drop, as we can be much more selective in where we live after my military service is complete.

Estimating our post-FI lifestyle is a bit of guessing game, but I estimate that our invested assets could replace around 18% of our post-FI life. We’re getting there and are still on track for FI by age 40!

Do you budget? Do you use a website to budget? Do you think we're being too lazy with regards to our budgeting or is not worrying about our expenses while we invest 50% of our income okay?

6 thoughts on “I Hate Budgeting: 2015-2016 Expenses and Investments”

  1. Spencer, if you have some time, you should write up an article regarding your choice to fund traditional TSP/IRA accounts over Roth. In an earlier article, you wrote about the benefits of using a Roth for military members, but you’ve seemed to jump the fence. Now, I’m pretty sure I understand why, especially after reading articles from GoCurry (http://www.gocurrycracker.com/roth-sucks/) and MadFientiest (http://www.madfientist.com/traditional-ira-vs-roth-ira/), but I’m curious if there are are any specific military factors that impact the strategies listed in those articles. Curious on your thoughts. Thanks,

    • Ben, you shacked it with those links. Those are exactly the articles that got me thinking about the Roth vs. Traditional debate more. My strategy now is if I’m paying any taxes in a year, I will contribute to the Traditional IRAs and TSP to lower my current year tax burden, invest those savings, and reap the benefit years down the line. If I receive the majority of my pay combat zone tax free (CZTE), then I will prioritize my Roth contributions. Next year I thought I would be deploying for 6 months CZTE, but now I may be going for a 2 year PCS to a different CZTE area. I will be writing an article explaining my strategy for maximizing my TSP contributions next year.

  2. Great job on your goal to becoming FI at 40. I only have one question. Can you touch your TSP money before the age of 59.5? I would think that if you wanted to be FI by 40, you would have more money in taxable accounts since you can access that money freely. I ask this because I am in the same dilemma. I’m trying to figure out if I should maximize my TSP or just invest in a taxable account since I want to be able to reach FI before 59.5. I was thinking of just contributing enough to stay at 15% tax bracket and the rest into Betterment or Vanguard. What are your thought?

    • There are many ways of accessing tax advantaged money before the 59.5 cutoff. The Madfientist detailed a few of these strategies. Personally, I’m taking advantage of all the tax advantaged accounts I can and investing the tax savings today for better future returns. While I plan on being financially independent by age 40, I don’t plan on cutting off all of my income sources. I don’t know the exact mixture of tax advantaged and regular investment accounts to have at this time, but when I do I will write a post about it!

  3. Hi, I thought I read somewhere that being in the military counts as having a pension (even if you don’t go the full 20) and so you lose the pre tax benefits of a traditional IRA. If this is the case wouldn’t you want to go Roth? Thanks!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.